A few weeks ago, one of my copywriter friends sent me a message I haven’t been able to stop thinking about.
She’d been working with a local business whose owners hated two things about their homepage. They hated having their address above the fold, and they thought the headlines were boring. My friend held her ground and told them that’s what’s best for SEO. Then she asked me a question as a copywriter: how do you balance searchable and fun?
Episode 10 of Name Brand is my answer. We get into why the so-called boring stuff goes where it goes, where all the fun gets to live instead, and a confession about my own website that I’m a little embarrassed to share.
Why owners push back on plain headlines
If you own a business where the experience is a big part of what people pay for, you’ve probably spent years making things feel special. You’ve thought about the lighting and the little note tucked into every bag, so of course your homepage headline feels like one more place to be charming. There’s also a fear underneath it. Plenty of owners look at their competitors and see the same website over and over, and a plain headline can feel like signing up to blend in.
I love a great line as much as anybody. I’ve also spent a lot of time inside analytics for my clients, and I’ve seen how people behave in the first few seconds on a homepage. They scan it the way you scan a menu when you’re starving. A clever headline asks them to stop and decode something, and a lot of them will hit the back button first.
What guests and Google need first
A first-time visitor needs to know what you are, where you are, whether you’re open, and how to book or buy. If they can find those things without scrolling, the top of your homepage has done its job. Search engines are looking for similar information. When someone types “brunch downtown Greenville,” Google wants the page that answers the kind of business and the location as plainly as possible, and one of the first places it looks is your main headline. If that headline says “Where the magic happens,” neither Google nor the person scrolling the results can tell whether you’re a bakery, a spa, or a theme park.
In the episode, I walk through which spots on a page stay plain and searchable, where the personality gets to show up instead, and an example from Renee Burroughs Design, a florist client in Greenville. Her wedding flower preservation page has about the most straightforward headline you can imagine, and it does well in search all the time.
What we’re talking about in this episode
These are the ideas I’d want you to walk away with from Episode 10.
What a visitor needs right away: What you are, where you are, whether you’re open, and how to book, all before they scroll.
Where search engines look first: Your main headline, page title, meta description, and first paragraph should stay plain and specific.
Why your address belongs near the top: It helps you show up in local and map searches, and it answers a guest’s first question.
Where the personality goes: Photography, fonts, layout, subheadings, and your About page all have plenty of room for it.
My own SEO confession: The thing you’re best at for other people is often the first thing you neglect for yourself.
Listen to Episode 10 of Name Brand
Pull up your homepage on your phone and don’t scroll. From that first screen alone, could a stranger tell what you are, where you are, and how to book or buy? Then search for yourself the way a new customer would, with your kind of business plus your town, and see where you show up.
The episode has a few more questions to take back to your own homepage, and I’m asking every one of them about mine right now.
Mentioned in this episode

